NPCI Defends New UPI MDR Framework, Says Customers Cannot Be Charged Extra

The National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) has defended its revised Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) framework for UPI transactions before the Supreme Court, arguing that the proposed charges are necessary to sustain India’s digital payments infrastructure. The organisation has maintained that merchants and UPI applications cannot transfer the additional cost to customers through separate payment fees.

In a counter-affidavit filed on November 3, NPCI said the revised framework introduces a charge of up to 0.4% on person-to-merchant (P2M) transactions exceeding ₹2,000. However, person-to-person transfers and transactions involving eligible small merchants will continue to remain free.

The submission comes amid a legal challenge to the revised UPI charging framework and concerns over whether the new merchant charges could eventually affect consumers.

Only a Small Share of UPI Merchant Transactions to Attract MDR

NPCI has argued that the proposed MDR will cover a limited portion of UPI transactions. According to its estimates, around 70% of all UPI transactions are person-to-person transfers, while approximately 96% of P2M transactions are valued at ₹2,000 or below.

This means that only about 4% of merchant transactions are expected to fall under the revised MDR framework.

The charge will be capped at 0.4% for eligible transactions above ₹2,000. Small merchants classified under the P2PM category, including those receiving up to ₹1 lakh in monthly UPI credits, will remain exempt.

NPCI has also compared the proposed rate with charges applicable to credit and debit card transactions, describing the 0.4% ceiling as significantly lower.

Although the original circular scheduled the framework’s implementation for October 15, NPCI has postponed its rollout. No revised implementation date was specified in the counter-affidavit, as reported.

Merchants and UPI Apps Cannot Add Charges to Customer Payments

A key part of NPCI’s submission concerns the protection of consumers from additional payment costs.

The organisation stated that merchants, payer banks and third-party UPI application providers cannot pass the MDR on to customers. It described this restriction as a binding requirement under its service-level agreements rather than a voluntary policy assurance.

NPCI further warned that UPI application providers or banks violating the directive could face compliance action or termination of their UPI membership.

It also rejected concerns that merchants might indirectly recover the charge by increasing prices across their businesses. According to NPCI, applying MDR only to selected transactions above a specified threshold does not provide sufficient grounds for merchants to revise prices for their entire customer base.

Why NPCI Wants a Revenue Model for UPI

Beyond defending the legality of the framework, NPCI has argued that India’s zero-MDR structure has created a financial gap in maintaining the UPI network.

The organisation said operating a payment system that processes billions of transactions requires continuous investment in cybersecurity, fraud prevention, infrastructure resilience and customer support. However, the absence of a sustainable revenue model has limited the industry’s ability to fund these requirements.

To support its argument, NPCI referred to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance’s Thirty-Second Report on Demands for Grants for 2026-27.

The report noted that the government’s ₹2,000 crore allocation to compensate for zero-MDR costs covered only 11% of industry operating costs and 14% of potential MDR collections.

The Finance Ministry had estimated the industry’s operating costs at ₹20,700 crore, compared with the ₹2,000 crore allocation. The committee subsequently recommended exploring a self-reliant, tiered revenue model for the digital payments ecosystem.

NPCI also stated that 5% of each entity’s MDR share would be directed towards a dedicated UPI adoption programme for small merchants with an annual turnover of up to ₹20 lakh, subject to specified exclusions.

Legal Dispute Centres on NPCI’s Authority to Levy Charges

NPCI has defended its authority to introduce the revised MDR framework by referring to the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007.

It said the Reserve Bank of India authorised it in August 2016 to operate UPI under Section 4 of the Act. NPCI has also cited Sections 20 and 21 to support its authority to determine and disclose charges for payment systems.

The dispute also involves Section 10A of the Act, which was amended through the Taxation and Other Laws (Amendment) Act, 2026.

NPCI argued that the amendment does not itself impose MDR or grant it new powers to determine rates. Instead, it identifies payment modes that are exempt from charges, while authorised payment system operators retain the ability to levy charges on other modes.

A notification issued by the Centre on September 14 identified two exempt categories: RuPay debit card transactions, irrespective of value, and UPI transactions of up to ₹2,000. NPCI issued its revised MDR circular on September 15, 2026.

The organisation has further argued that MDR is a commercial charge distributed among participants in the UPI ecosystem, rather than a tax or government fee. It has defended the framework’s classifications based on transaction value, merchant category and merchant size, stating that these distinctions are intended to support a sustainable and inclusive payment system.

What the Revised Framework Means for India’s UPI Ecosystem

The dispute highlights the challenge of balancing free digital payments for consumers with the financial requirements of maintaining a large-scale payment infrastructure.

While NPCI has argued that a limited MDR on eligible merchant transactions can help fund the UPI ecosystem, it has maintained that the cost must not be transferred to customers through additional payment charges.

The legal challenge will also bring attention to the authority of payment system operators to introduce commercial charges and the safeguards required to protect users as India’s digital payments network continues to expand.

-By: Aakriti Jaiswal

Picture of Indian BFSI Times

Indian BFSI Times

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *